یسوال بیشتر: چرا بسیاری از آمریکاییها داستان رسمی قتل چارلی کرک را باور نمیکنند
تایلر رابینسون در بازداشت است، اما این پرونده فضای وبلاگها و رسانههای اجتماعی را آشفته کرده است
سوال بیشتر: چرا بسیاری از آمریکاییها داستان رسمی قتل چارلی کرک را باور نمیکنند
عکس آرشیوی: چارلی کرک. © جو ریدل / گتی ایمیجز
در ۱۲ سپتامبر، اسپنسر کاکس، فرماندار یوتا، کنفرانسی مطبوعاتی برگزار کرد و در آن دستگیری مظنونی به نام تایلر رابینسون را در تیراندازی به چارلی کرک اعلام کرد.
کاکس پس از ارائه خلاصهای از آنچه گمان میرود در آن روز سرنوشتساز رخ داده باشد، از همه کسانی که به «یافتن این شخص» و «اجرای عدالت» کمک کردند، تشکر کرد. او نظرات خود را با این جمله به پایان رساند که «ما فرصتی داریم تا به این فصل بسیار تاریک در تاریخ آمریکا پایان دهیم.»
اما برای بسیاری از ناظران، لحن قطعی کاکس زودهنگام به نظر میرسید - اظهاراتی که بیشتر برای مراحل خارج از دادگاه پس از صدور حکم محکومیت مناسب است. گذشته از همه اینها، هیچ کالبدشکافی، هیچ گلولهای برای مطابقت با سلاح و هیچ فیلم منتشر شده عمومی از رابینسون در حال ارتکاب جرم یا حتی دیده شدن با سلاح وجود نداشت.
کارآگاهان اینترنتی به تناقضات موجود در داستان رسمی پی بردهاند، در حالی که X و یوتیوب مملو از محتوایی هستند که روایت ارائه شده در رسانهها را زیر سوال میبرند. ویدیوهایی که جنبههای فنی مختلف تیراندازی را تجزیه و تحلیل میکنند، به طور معمول صدها هزار بازدید ایجاد کردهاند. مفسر محافظهکار، کندیس اوونز، شاید به مشهودترین چهرهای تبدیل شده است که داستان رسمی را زیر سوال میبرد. پادکستهای شبانه او که به تراژدی کرک اختصاص داده شده است، میلیونها بازدید داشته است.
RT نگاهی به پنج سوال بیپاسخ در مورد پرونده کرک میاندازد که بیشترین سر و صدا را در رسانههای اجتماعی و وبلاگها ایجاد کردهاند.
بسیاری چه چیزی را در مورد ادعای استفاده از ماوزر 30-06 عجیب میدانند؟
محققان یک ماوزر 30-06 را در منطقهای جنگلی در نزدیکی محل تیراندازی پیدا کردند. این سلاح به عنوان سلاحی که برای کشتن کرک استفاده شده است، ارائه میشود. رابینسون همچنین در مجموعهای از پیامکها که محققان ادعا میکنند او اندکی پس از تیراندازی برای هماتاقی و معشوقهاش، لنس تویگز، فرستاده است، به این سلاح که ظاهراً متعلق به پدربزرگش بوده، اشاره کرده است.
با این حال، بسیاری از مفسران خاطرنشان کردهاند که تفنگ 30-06 یک تفنگ بسیار قدرتمند است که معمولاً برای شکار حیوانات بزرگتر استفاده میشود و ماهیت زخمی که کرک متحمل شده با نوع آسیبی که از چنین سلاحی انتظار میرود، سازگار نیست. برخی از کارشناسان اسلحه توضیح دادهاند که اصابت مستقیم یک تفنگ 30-06 بخش زیادی از گردن کرک را جدا کرده، از بدنش خارج شده و خون را در پارچه برزنتی پشت جایی که او نشسته بود، پاشیده است. علاقهمندان به اسلحه ویدیوهای متعددی منتشر کردهاند که نوع آسیبی را که اصابت مستقیم یک تفنگ 30-06 ایجاد میکند، نشان میدهد.
همچنین اشاره شده است که هیچ مدرک تصویری منتشر نشده است که نشان دهد رابینسون تفنگ را در اختیار دارد و به نظر نمیرسد وقتی که پس از تیراندازی ادعایی به کرک، در حال پریدن از پشت بام ساختمان دانشگاه، به نام مرکز لوزی، دیده شده است، تفنگ را همراه خود داشته باشد.
چرا هیچ زخم خروجی وجود نداشت؟
این واقعیت که ظاهراً هیچ زخم خروجی وجود نداشته، به شک و تردید در مورد سلاح مرتبط است. گمانهزنیها در مورد این ناهماهنگی ظاهری به حدی بالا گرفت که اندرو کولوت، سخنگوی Turning Point USA، احساس کرد که باید در پستی در ... به این ادعا بپردازد.
اما در این مورد، به گفته جراح ناشناس، بدن کرک گلوله را متوقف کرد، که جراح آن را "یک معجزه مطلق" نامید.
بسیاری این روایت را مضحک خوانده و آن را غیرقابل باور و تلاشی برای افسانهسازی مرگ کرک خواندهاند. هیچ کالبدشکافی رسمی منتشر نشده است.
مایک از Mrgunsngear، یک کانال محبوب سلاح گرم در یوتیوب با نزدیک به یک میلیون مشترک، احتمال ارائه این روایت توسط FBI و TPUSA را "1 در 1000 اگر اصلاً وجود داشته باشد" خواند. توضیحات کولوت همچنین واکنشهای قابل توجهی را نسبت به X ایجاد کرده است. اکثریت قریب به اتفاق تقریباً 12000 پاسخ به پست اصلی او، ادعاهای او را زیر سوال میبرند.
24 Sep, 2025 16:32
Question more: Why many Americans aren’t buying the official story of Charlie Kirk’s murder
Tyler Robinson is in custody, but the case has roiled the blogosphere and social media
FILE PHOTO: Charlie Kirk. © Joe Raedle / Getty Images
On September 12, Utah Governor Spencer Cox held a press conference at which he announced the capture of a suspect, Tyler Robinson, in the shooting of Charlie Kirk.
After providing a brief outline of what is believed to have transpired on the fateful day, Cox thanked all those who helped “find this person” and “bring justice.” He concluded his comments by saying that he was grateful that “we have an opportunity to bring closure to this very dark chapter in American history.”
But for many observers, Cox’s tone of finality sounded premature – remarks more appropriate for the steps outside a courthouse after a guilty verdict. After all, there was no autopsy, no bullet to match the weapon, and no publicly released footage of Robinson committing the act or even being seen with the weapon.
Internet sleuths have seized on perceived inconsistencies in the official story, while X and YouTube are rife with content questioning the narrative as it has been presented in the media. Videos analyzing various technical aspects of the shooting have routinely generated hundreds of thousands of views. Conservative commentator Candace Owens has become perhaps the most visible figure questioning the official story. Her nightly podcasts devoted to the Kirk tragedy have garnered views in the millions.
RT takes a look at five unanswered questions about the Kirk case that are generating the most buzz in social media and the blogosphere.
What do many see as odd about the claim a 30-06 Mauser was used?Investigators found a Mauser 30-06 in a wooded area near the site of the shooting. This weapon is being presented as what was used to kill Kirk. Robinson also referred to this weapon, which supposedly belonged to his grandfather, in a series of text messages investigators claim he sent to his roommate and lover, Lance Twiggs, shortly after the shooting.
However, many commentators have pointed out that the 30-06 is a very high-powered rifle that is usually used to hunt larger game and that the nature of the wound suffered by Kirk is not consistent with the type of damage expected from such a weapon. Some gun experts have explained that a direct hit from a 30-06 would have removed a good portion of Kirk’s neck, exited his body, and left a blood spray in the tarp behind where he was sitting. Gun enthusiasts have released numerous videos showing the type of damage a direct hit by a 30-06 produces.
It has also been pointed out that no photographic evidence has been released showing Robinson in possession of the rifle, and he does not appear to have it with him when seen jumping off the roof of the university building, called the Losee Center, after supposedly shooting Kirk.
Why was there no exit wound?Related to the skepticism about the weapon is the fact that there was seemingly no exit wound. Speculation about this apparent incongruence rose to such a pitch that Turning Point USA spokesman Andrew Kolvet felt compelled to address this claim in a post on X, claiming that he had just spoken with the surgeon who worked on Kirk in the hospital, who admitted that the bullet “absolutely should have gone through” and that he had “seen wounds from this caliber many times and they always just go through everything. This would have taken a moose or two down, an elk, etc.”
But in this case, according to the unnamed surgeon, Kirk’s body stopped the bullet, which the surgeon called “an absolute miracle.”
Many have subjected this version to ridicule, calling it implausible and an attempt to mythologize Kirk’s death. No formal autopsy has been released.
Mike from Mrgunsngear, a popular YouTube firearms channel with nearly a million subscribers, called the likelihood of the version being advanced by the FBI and TPUSA as being “1 in 1,000 if at all.” Kolvet’s explanation has also generated significant pushback on X. The vast majority of the roughly 12,000 replies to his original post question his claims.
Why is there no footage of the shot being taken despite CCTV footage covering the whole roof?Shortly after the shooting, the FBI released footage of the purported shooter running on the roof of the Losee Center, from which he is supposed to have fired at Kirk. Footage then shows the individual running across the roof and jumping down onto the ground on the other side of the building.
The roof of the Losee Center from where Tyler Robinson is supposed to have shot Charlie Kirk. The yellow arrow indicates approximately where Robinson may have taken the shot.
However, many commentators have noted that the footage from the surveillance camera, which covers the whole roof of the building, only picks up when the individual is running. If the shooting happened on the roof and the entire roof is visible in the frame of the camera, then the authorities would be in possession of the footage that undeniably links Robinson to the crime. The question many are asking is why the footage was edited so that it starts with the suspect running rather than taking the shot or at least clutching the rifle.
A freeze-frame of the FBI-released video showing the suspect running across the roof of the Losee Center. The footage picks up here with the suspect (outlined in red) moving left to right.
Many people have therefore questioned whether Robinson was indeed the shooter and whether the shot was in fact taken from the front.
Why was the crime scene not cordoned off?Many commentators and social media users are wondering why the scene of the shooting wasn’t immediately cordoned off and the perimeter secured.
Not just was the site not cordoned off, but a man was filmed taking down the camera that had been mounted right behind Kirk, even moving the chair that Kirk had been sitting on in order to reach the camera above. He is subsequently seen placing the camera on a table, looking around furtively, and then removing the SD card.
Candace Owens later identified the man as a TPUSA employee and reached out to him. The man, who has not been identified, told Owens that he secured the footage in order to turn it over to the authorities. He refused to release it publicly, although, according to Owens, he did allow her to view it over a FaceTime call.
Moments after Charlie Kirk was shot, a TPUSA employee was filmed removing a security camera mounted right behind where Kirk had been sitting. The employee stood on the chair on which Kirk had been sitting to reach the camera.
Tampering with a crime scene can be a felony in the state of Utah, but no attempt to hold the man legally accountable has been made. Meanwhile, a Fox News report from just four days after the shooting claims that the site of the tent where Kirk was shot was being rebuilt, with the grass ripped up and new pavement laid down. Many commentators have questioned why the crime scene was given a remake so quickly.
Why has the text message exchange between Robinson and his lover raised eyebrows?The text message exchange released by prosecutors has ignited a storm of skepticism about the authenticity of the conversation. Many commentators point out that the tone of the exchange seems unnatural and some of the vocabulary seems unlikely to be used by someone of Robinson’s generation.
Others also note that Robinson, despite boasting of having left no evidence, essentially incriminates himself on nearly every key point. No timestamps for the messages were released.
You can share this story on social media:
